The state of Karnataka had passed the Cow slaughter bill a year ago amidst a furore in the legislative assembly with the lukewarm Congress and JD(S) having spineless objections. There was no vote count and division of votes. Through an oral vote the bill passed without debate as the opposition was eating glue over it. The ruling Government is resorting to unfair rightist policies which in a way infringes the constitutional rights.
The most prominent reason cited for the ban, is that the Cow is a sacred animal and cannot be slaughtered for any purpose. Well, 'ignorant' could be an understatement for the logic applied by our 'visionary' leaders who actually seem to be 'vision impaired' for the plain fact that, the bill is another extension of a draconian mindset. I wonder if banning cow slaughter would help at all. A huge section of the populace depends on the livelihood of products obtained by Cow slaughter. Beef is the staple non-veg food for a larger section of middle class people who cannot afford chicken, mutton or seafood on a regular staple basis.
Will the Government regulate other non-veg foods to compensate for the ban? Will it reduce Muttton and Chicken prices in this era of spiralling inflation? As per the constitution and referencing various wildlfie and forest acts, any slaugter, poaching or possession of an endangered or protected species that could create imbalance in the ecology, makes a thumping sense and should be rightly observed. With this point in the back of our minds, it's very unfair to ban Cow claughter. Cattle is domesticated and can easily be bred and replenished. It would not make sense if a Government headed by an Islamic cabinet in an Indian state decides to ban Pork citing that it hurts the sentiments of the "representative" voter. Meddling with people's right of dining lifestyle is a dangerous stunt.
There are other vital issues that would arise by the bill. Leather, durables, laboratory products and pharmaceutical raw materials are some other products obtained by cattle slaughter. The livelihood of many people dependent on these industries would take a big hit and the Government seems very myopic on this front. What about the cattle that have grown old? The poor farmers who cannot afford to manitain them would look to stabling the old cattle at the government aided cattle homes that lack basic amenities and more or less the cattle are left to perish by an agonising death. If cow slaughter ban is effected, there would be a humungous rush towards these shelter homes to dump the old and void cattle that are apparently of no use. So will they not slaughter them to altleast salvage the products that could be obtained or left to die a slow merciless death? It would be so hypocritical if some contagious disease hits the cattle and culling is allowed. At a time where we still have evloving forest and land aquisition laws which have continual amendments, there is no concrete plan to provide fodder to these cattle. They need green grazing pastures to produce healthy offsprings and maintain the cattle quality. On one hand, we have a very tepid effort towards afforestation and on the other hand we want to provide food for cattle while millions of children in India under the age group of 5 are malnourished according the UN report.
Coming back to the point that the cow being a sacred animal, the pantheism laws are not fully conformed by the people who claim cows to be sacred. the Palm, Neem, Sandalwood, Banana, Mango trees etc are considered very sacred and yet they are killed for their products and relished in a lip smacking manner. Will they introduce a bill banning felling of these trees? The rice and the wheat plant is uprooted and "killed" to provide sustainance for the 'vegans' who apparently don't indulge in blooshed and any killing.
Another preposterous reason cited was that the ban was effective in Gujarat and other states ( which are predominantly headed by so called right conservatives) and have apparently received very good response. They conveniently push under the carpet, the fact that alcohol has been banned too. So why not have a ban on alcohol that has infact ruined millions of lives and spread cirhossis and other fatal ailments. Wife beating and premature unnatural deaths are the worst consequences that have ruined the quality of life. Banning something that is basic in nature will surely effect illegal acivities and create a bigger mess. In Gujarat, beef and alcohol are available illegally and ultimately the government is losing out on the revenue since these are banned and there is no provision to collect taxes on illegal items. It's an absurd legislation.
Currently, the Karnataka cow slaughter bill has been sent back by the President's office to the legislative assembly for modicifations. A very "satisfying and encouraging" modification that can really make the cow slaughter bill highly plausible and "significant" that addresses all the grievances - Omitting Buffaloes from the bill!!!!!!!